“Perry out, Gingrich surging” screamed an ABC News headline. The mental image of a surging Gingrich is too gruesome for me to hold for more than a few seconds, so instead I’ll turn my thoughts to the error-strewn Perry campaign for the Republican presidential nomination, and just some examples of the verbal delinquency that contributed to his downfall.
Rick Perry could never be described as a modest man, though, to paraphrase Winston Churchill, he seems to have a great deal to be modest about. But even he could not carry in the face of widespread ridicule (though that never stopped George Bush). So here are just a few things where – to mangle a cliché -- he stepped up to the plate without a paddle:
1 – His grasp of American history:
"The reason that we fought the Revolution in the 16th century — was to get away from that kind of onerous crown, if you will." —he was only two centuries out.
2 – His grasp of his own campaign priorities during a debate:
On struggling to name the three federal agencies he would cut if he were elected president, Perry failed to remember the third one. In the end, he could only manage: “Oops”.
3 – His grasp of foreign policy and the basic laws of physics:
Having on an earlier occasion mixed up Iran with Iraq, Perry was determined to show he was clued up on the politics of the Middle East. He said that given the chance Iran would invade Iraq, “literally at the speed of light”.
Now Perry’s linguistic foibles hardly begin to compare with those of George W Bush whose legacy of ‘Bushisms’ is fondly missed, at least by me [I mean who could forget: “I remember meeting a mother of a child who was abducted by the North Koreans right here in the Oval Office."]. And some people have defended Perry, harking back to ancient precedents of language usage stating such use “although infelicitous, cannot be said to be incorrect”. However, few other misused and abused words have such capacity to cause unintended mirth as ‘literally’.
Anyone who wants to be taken seriously, therefore, should probably avoid using it in speech or writing when the effect might be distracting or comic [such as the peerless:"...My grandfather, George VI, who had literally been catapulted onto the throne…" (attributed to Prince Edward)]. Writers and poets can get away with using words figuratively, and the word `literally' can sometimes be used to good effect if it reinforces a strong verbal image [such as: "Every day with me is literally another yesterday, for it is exactly the same" (Alexander Pope, 1708)]. But Rick Perry? For a gaffe prone Republican with his eye on the top job, choosing words with care matters a lot. And my main objection to literally in this context, is that it just sounds silly.
No comments:
Post a Comment