Friday, 24 February 2012

Live and dangerous: the perils of live broadcasting


Live broadcasting is a dangerous place. Many an innocent slip of the tongue has propelled even the most skilled presenters to temporary notoriety, and – of course – there are the not-so-innocent ones as well.

Remember James Naughtie, who got into a muddle a while back on BBC Radio 4 while introducing the Culture Secretary, Jeremy Hunt? Common decency prevents me from repeating his act of verbal delinquency here, but if you didn’t hear it and should want to, it is still available on YouTube. Mr Naughtie said at the time that his mistake was a simple Spoonerism, one of the many hazards that presenters are prey to. Many newspaper column inches were devoted to this subject and the consensus is that it was rather a Freudian slip. It is not for me to analyse here what may or may not be Mr Naughtie’s opinion of a government minister, but his error was certainly not a Spoonerism. Nicky Campbell once committed the same radio sin, when he introduced the Master of the West Kent Hunt (also available on YouTube) and transposed the consonents in two of the words. I’ll leave you to guess which two. And that transposition of letters is a Spoonerism, something that is named after the Reverend WA Spooner, late of New College, Oxford, who became famous for his inadvertent verbal tics. He once referred in the pulpit to a hymn as ‘Kinquering Kongs their Titles Take’ (instead, of course, of conquering kings...).  Spoonerisms are a gift to comedians, as in the example “I’d rather have a bottle in front of me, than a frontal lobotomy”, which has been variously attributed to WC Fields, Tom Waits and Dorothy Parker. Dean Martin took this a step further when he said “I’d rather have a free bottle in front of me than a pre-frontal lobotomy”. But perhaps my favourite Spoonerism of all was uttered by Richard Dimbleby on BBC radio during the Coronation of Queen Elizabeth II in 1953, when, it is said, he referred to “the royal carriage, closely followed by the Royal Arse Hortillery”.

It’s not just Spoonerisms that trip people up. Even when radio broadcasters do manage to avoid the obvious pitfalls of the obscene and the unforeseen, there is an air of false security caused by the mistaken belief that they cannot be seen by viewers. Witness the woes of chief Womble, Mike Batt, who unwittingly unmasked himself, quite literally, in front of a nationwide audience of horrified children. Batt, who was appearing on Simon Mayo’s BBC Radio 2 programme last December, was dressed in a full Orinoco Womble suit (he never travels without one, apparently) for a lusty performance of the seasonal classic, ‘Wombling Merry Christmas’. A radio studio can get pretty hot, so, as soon as the song was over, and, thinking that he couldn’t be seen, Batt ripped off the head of his costume. Calamity! Thousands of children tuning in by webcam for what they thought was going to be a jolly Christmas scene, witnessed instead their hero’s decapitation. It may have affected their development forever. It certainly affected their parents, who grumbled in their hundreds to the BBC. It seems that some of the children had been traumatised by the discovery that perhaps The Wombles weren’t real after all. And one six-year old boy thought that Batt had been eaten by Orinoco Womble. Let us hope he does not find out about Santa Claus any time soon!

The next day, in an attempt at damage limitation, Mr Batt informed his audience, via his Twitter feed, that The Wombles were indeed real, and that he had had no option but to stand in at the last minute for Orinoco, who had been overcome by the heat of the studio lights. “Everyone knows that Wombles can’t remove their heads”, said Batt.
So, while live media performances can be perilous, you might imagine the life of a TV subtitler to be altogether more serene. Not a bit of it! The BBC has lately had to defend itself against a tirade from ‘deaf groups’ (what is a deaf group? I don’t know) against ludicrous subtitles. Pre-recorded subtitles are done before transmission and appear in time with the programme. Live subtitles, however, are made by stenographers, typing words phonetically as they listen to a show, or with speech recognition, where someone talks into a microphone. And that is where the trouble starts. Over the last few years, hard-of-hearing viewers have, apparently, been feeling confused by subtitles such as these:
·         A request during the Queen Mother’s funeral for “...a moment’s ‘violence’ for the Queen Mother” (instead of silence)
·         A town that was promised “...a visit from the ‘Archbitch’ of Canterbury” (instead of Archbishop)
and, my favourite,
·         A story about “...the leader of the Labour Party, ‘Ed Miller Band’”. Write your own jokes about his brother Glenn... er, David.

There have been, of course, plenty of the obligatory faux pas involving ‘willies’ for wellies, but it would be beneath me to record them here.

Tuesday, 14 February 2012

Friday, 10 February 2012

Gove, tell it on the mountain (’cause the face ain’t listening)

A few weeks ago, Michael Gove MP, Secretary of State for Education, went off to south London to talk to pupils at Haberdashers’ Aske's Hatcham College, a secondary school in Lewisham.

“Thank you boys and girls...” he began. This was not a good start. The teenagers, who had, no doubt, been frogmarched to the school hall, told to look interested, and forced to listen to their VIP guest, all switched off at that moment. When you’re giving a speech it’s hard to come back from a bad beginning, but not impossible if you’ve got something interesting to say. But Gove went on: “Schools are continually finding new ways to work together. There are 403 converter academies in approximately 138 chains. These chains range from multi-academy trusts with shared governance and leadership, to looser collaborative partnerships.” Mr Gove read from a script and droned on at some length, and in considerable detail, about matters that were neither of interest nor direct relevance to his audience. Could you give a damn? No? Well neither did they. The YouTube clip here shows the audience’s reaction and not only is it not rapturous, but more than a few of them seem to be asleep:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qQL5L31-1E.


The first rule of speechwriting, in fact the first rule of any kind of writing, is to work out who your audience is. Once you’ve analysed who they are, why they’ll be there and what their common purpose is, you are then well prepared to say something they might want to hear or read. The Department of Education’s speechwriters are probably so used to churning out these speeches for political positioning that they probably didn’t stop to consider who would be listening to this one. And this speech would have been better aimed at a party conference, educational managers or the media rather than schoolchildren. Gove, who was an accomplished journalist, was once president of the Oxford Union and is, on the whole, an excellent and experienced public speaker, should have known better.

A couple of weeks later, further up the road in south-east London, Deptford Green secondary school prepared to receive their VIP guest, who had been supplied by a new programme called Speakers for Schools (www.speakers4schools.org). Speakers for Schools was set up by the BBC’s Robert Peston, in conjunction with the Education and Employers Taskforce, to provide a wide variety of inspirational speakers for state schools. A teacher, who had applied to the programme for someone interesting to come and address her pupils, had said: “we don't want a boring stuffy professor who doesn't know how to speak to teenagers.” Well they got lucky. They got very lucky. They got Bill Gates. Gates, who received a standing ovation from a packed school hall before he even began to speak, engaged the students with his personal account of how he set up Microsoft, how he became rich, and why he planned to give most of his money away through The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. He spoke to, not at his audience, without notes and then listened to their own ideas about how he and his Foundation could help to alleviate some of the world’s most pressing problems, such as poverty. You can see a clip of Gates in action here:

The difference in styles leaves you in no doubt about which group of listeners was left feeling the most inspired and the comparison between these two approaches underlines just how important it is to know your audience.

Sunday, 5 February 2012

And speaking of weather...

Driving along the M62 in freezing fog, visibility down to four of five yards. No one else on the road, or if there is, you can't see them. Up ahead, there's a sign with a message flashing on it.You crawl towards it, and just about come to a halt trying to read it. It says F O G.

Simon Armitage, All Points North (Penguin Books, 1998)

You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows

Well here we are again; it’s that time of year when the weather makes front page news – for all the wrong reasons. Hundreds of flights have been cancelled, trains have shuddered to a halt if they set off at all, and those football matches that did get played took place in farcical conditions. I’d call it ‘Black Saturday’ if it hadn’t all been so white. Yes, it’s snowing! For the game between Stoke City and Sunderland yesterday the groundsmen painted the lines on the pitch blue for greater visibility, not that it made much difference after 90 minutes of solid snowfall.
We should have known it would be like this because last week it was Groundhog Day. All around the world, well perhaps all over North America at least, groundhogs (also known as woodchucks) were rudely awakened from happy hibernation to wink at the waiting world and indicate how much longer winter would last. It doesn’t surprise me that consensus among groundhogs is just about as strong as it in the Met Office. Wiarton Willie from Ottawa, Shubenacadie Sam from Nova Scotia, and General Beauregard Lee from Georgia all decided there would be an early spring. However, Balzac Billie from Alberta, Winnipeg Willow, and the granddaddy of groundhogs everywhere – Punxsutawney Phil from Pennsylvania – emerged from their burrows, saw their shadows, and hurried back inside as fast as their legs could scurry. This is apparently a sure sign that winter will last for another six weeks. According to his minder, Phil the Punxsutawney pundit has never been wrong; after all, “it is always winter somewhere”.
Phil may be a phenomenal forecaster but what he is not is a bellwether (frequently misspelt ‘bellweather’). A bellwether is a sheep, for one thing. Confusing! The meaning of bellwether seems to have been been corrupted over the years to be used as ‘a harbinger or foreteller of events’. But what it really means is to lead the pack or show the way forward. The bellwether sheep at the head of a flock used to wear a bell around his neck, and – sheep being sheep – all the others would follow.
In US presidential elections, a bellwether state is one that tends to vote reliably for the winner. With notable exceptions, in recent years the eventual winner has carried states such as Florida, Missouri and Ohio. Bellwether states don’t always go for the winner. But this is the kind statistic that has the power to get psephologists excited and make an otherwise down-to-earth candidate superstitious. And of all the bellwether states, Ohio’s claim to success is the strongest. Not only has it voted for every presidential winner since the 1964 election, but no Republican candidate has ever won the presidency without taking Ohio.