A few weeks ago, Michael Gove MP, Secretary of State for Education, went off to south London to talk to pupils at Haberdashers’ Aske's Hatcham College, a secondary school in Lewisham.
“Thank you boys and girls...” he began. This was not a good start. The teenagers, who had, no doubt, been frogmarched to the school hall, told to look interested, and forced to listen to their VIP guest, all switched off at that moment. When you’re giving a speech it’s hard to come back from a bad beginning, but not impossible if you’ve got something interesting to say. But Gove went on: “Schools are continually finding new ways to work together. There are 403 converter academies in approximately 138 chains. These chains range from multi-academy trusts with shared governance and leadership, to looser collaborative partnerships.” Mr Gove read from a script and droned on at some length, and in considerable detail, about matters that were neither of interest nor direct relevance to his audience. Could you give a damn? No? Well neither did they. The YouTube clip here shows the audience’s reaction and not only is it not rapturous, but more than a few of them seem to be asleep:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qQL5L31-1E.
The first rule of speechwriting, in fact the first rule of any kind of writing, is to work out who your audience is. Once you’ve analysed who they are, why they’ll be there and what their common purpose is, you are then well prepared to say something they might want to hear or read. The Department of Education’s speechwriters are probably so used to churning out these speeches for political positioning that they probably didn’t stop to consider who would be listening to this one. And this speech would have been better aimed at a party conference, educational managers or the media rather than schoolchildren. Gove, who was an accomplished journalist, was once president of the Oxford Union and is, on the whole, an excellent and experienced public speaker, should have known better.
A couple of weeks later, further up the road in south-east London, Deptford Green secondary school prepared to receive their VIP guest, who had been supplied by a new programme called Speakers for Schools (www.speakers4schools.org). Speakers for Schools was set up by the BBC’s Robert Peston, in conjunction with the Education and Employers Taskforce, to provide a wide variety of inspirational speakers for state schools. A teacher, who had applied to the programme for someone interesting to come and address her pupils, had said: “we don't want a boring stuffy professor who doesn't know how to speak to teenagers.” Well they got lucky. They got very lucky. They got Bill Gates. Gates, who received a standing ovation from a packed school hall before he even began to speak, engaged the students with his personal account of how he set up Microsoft, how he became rich, and why he planned to give most of his money away through The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. He spoke to, not at his audience, without notes and then listened to their own ideas about how he and his Foundation could help to alleviate some of the world’s most pressing problems, such as poverty. You can see a clip of Gates in action here:
The difference in styles leaves you in no doubt about which group of listeners was left feeling the most inspired and the comparison between these two approaches underlines just how important it is to know your audience.
No comments:
Post a Comment